Unlocking Knee Health: A Deep Dive Into The McMurray Test

Ms. Bernice Langosh DDS 06 Jul 2025

Knee pain can be debilitating, often stemming from injuries to crucial internal structures like the meniscus. When faced with such discomfort, understanding the diagnostic tools available becomes paramount. One of the most common and vital orthopedic examinations for assessing knee joint health and detecting potential issues, particularly meniscus tears, is the McMurray Test. This comprehensive guide will explore everything you need to know about this essential diagnostic procedure, from its underlying principles to what its results truly mean for your knee health.

Navigating the complexities of knee injuries requires precise diagnostic methods. The McMurray Test stands out as a cornerstone in the initial assessment of meniscal damage, offering invaluable insights into the integrity of these vital cartilaginous structures. Whether you're an athlete, an active individual, or simply someone experiencing persistent knee discomfort, understanding the mechanics and significance of the McMurray Test can empower you to engage more effectively with your healthcare provider on the path to recovery.

Understanding the Knee: Anatomy of the Meniscus
What is the McMurray Test?
- The Purpose and Principle Behind the Test
- When is the McMurray Test Performed?
Performing the McMurray Test: A Step-by-Step Guide
- Medial Meniscus Assessment
- Lateral Menial Assessment
Interpreting the McMurray Test Results
Accuracy, Limitations, and Complementary Diagnostics
Beyond Diagnosis: Treatment and Rehabilitation for Meniscal Tears
Other "McMurrays": Disambiguating the Term
Conclusion: Empowering Your Journey to Knee Recovery

Understanding the Knee: Anatomy of the Meniscus

Before delving into the specifics of the McMurray Test, it's crucial to grasp the anatomy of the knee, particularly the role of the menisci. The knee joint, one of the body's largest and most complex, is formed by the articulation of three bones: the femur (thigh bone), tibia (shin bone), and patella (kneecap). Within this intricate joint lie two crescent-shaped pieces of cartilage known as the menisci: the medial meniscus and the lateral meniscus.

These menisci act as vital shock absorbers, distributing stress across the joint surfaces and providing stability. They also facilitate smooth movement by increasing the contact area between the femur and tibia. The medial meniscus, located on the inner side of the knee, is C-shaped and less mobile, making it more susceptible to injury. The lateral meniscus, on the outer side, is more O-shaped and mobile, offering it slightly more protection. A tear in either of these structures can significantly impair knee function, leading to pain, swelling, and mechanical symptoms like clicking or locking.

What is the McMurray Test?

The McMurray Test, also known as the McMurray circumduction test, is a classic orthopedic special test used to evaluate individuals for tears in the meniscus of the knee. Developed by Dr. Thomas Porter McMurray in the early 20th century, this clinical assessment tool has remained a staple in physical examinations due to its ability to provoke symptoms indicative of meniscal damage. It's a series of knee and leg movements designed to apply stress to the medial and lateral meniscus, aiming to detect pain or a popping sensation that suggests a tear.

The Purpose and Principle Behind the Test

The primary purpose of the McMurray Test is to diagnose a torn meniscus. The test works on the principle of "trapping" a potentially torn piece of the meniscus between the femoral condyles and the tibial plateau. When a meniscus is torn, especially if it's a "bucket-handle" tear or a pedunculated tag of the meniscus, the torn fragment can become jammed between the joint surfaces during specific movements. This jamming action elicits pain, a palpable click, or a "pop" sensation, which are considered positive findings.

By systematically rotating the tibia (shin bone) while flexing and extending the knee, the examiner attempts to load different parts of the menisci. External rotation of the tibia combined with valgus stress (force applied to the outside of the knee) and extension primarily stresses the medial meniscus. Conversely, internal rotation of the tibia with varus stress (force applied to the inside of the knee) and extension targets the lateral meniscus. This targeted stress helps pinpoint which meniscus, if any, is affected.

When is the McMurray Test Performed?

The McMurray Test is a common orthopedic examination performed when a patient presents with symptoms suggestive of a meniscal injury. These symptoms often include:

Knee pain, especially with twisting or squatting movements.
Swelling around the knee joint.
Clicking, popping, or catching sensations within the knee.
Locking of the knee, where it gets stuck in a bent or straightened position.
Tenderness along the joint line.
Difficulty fully straightening or bending the knee.

Athletes, particularly those involved in sports requiring pivoting, jumping, and sudden stops (e.g., soccer, basketball, skiing), are at a higher risk for meniscal tears. However, tears can also occur in older individuals due to degenerative changes in the cartilage, even with minor trauma. A healthcare professional, such as an orthopedic surgeon, physical therapist, or sports medicine physician, will typically perform the McMurray Test as part of a comprehensive physical examination.

Performing the McMurray Test: A Step-by-Step Guide

Performing the McMurray Test requires a skilled examiner and a cooperative patient. The patient typically lies supine (on their back) on an examination table. The examiner positions themselves at the patient's side, near the knee being tested. The test is meticulously performed to assess both the medial and lateral menisci.

Medial Meniscus Assessment

To assess the medial meniscus, the following steps are generally followed:

The examiner holds the patient's knee with one hand, placing their fingers along the medial joint line (inner side of the knee) to palpate for any clicks or tenderness.
The other hand grasps the patient's heel or foot, allowing for control over the lower leg.
The knee is then fully flexed, bringing the heel towards the buttocks.
While maintaining full knee flexion, the examiner externally rotates the tibia (turns the foot outwards). This position helps to "open up" the medial compartment of the knee, making the medial meniscus more vulnerable to impingement.
With external rotation maintained, the examiner slowly extends the knee. As the knee extends, a valgus stress (pushing the knee inwards, creating an outward force on the lower leg) may also be applied to further load the medial meniscus.
The examiner carefully watches the patient's face for signs of pain and feels for any clicks or pops along the medial joint line. Pain or a palpable click/pop during this maneuver is indicative of a positive McMurray Test for a medial meniscus tear.

Lateral Meniscus Assessment

To assess the lateral meniscus, the procedure is similar but with opposite rotational and stress components:

The examiner again holds the patient's knee with one hand, placing their fingers along the lateral joint line (outer side of the knee) to palpate for any clicks or tenderness.
The other hand grasps the patient's heel or foot.
The knee is fully flexed.
While maintaining full knee flexion, the examiner internally rotates the tibia (turns the foot inwards). This position helps to "open up" the lateral compartment of the knee, making the lateral meniscus more vulnerable.
With internal rotation maintained, the examiner slowly extends the knee. As the knee extends, a varus stress (pushing the knee outwards, creating an inward force on the lower leg) may also be applied to further load the lateral meniscus.
Again, the examiner observes for pain and feels for any clicks or pops along the lateral joint line. Pain or a palpable click/pop during this maneuver is indicative of a positive McMurray Test for a lateral meniscus tear.

It's important for the examiner to be gentle yet firm, ensuring the full range of motion is tested while being mindful of the patient's pain threshold. This video shows how to perform the McMurray Test, one of the most commonly used clinical assessment tools to assess for meniscal injuries in the knee.

Interpreting the McMurray Test Results

Interpreting the results of the McMurray Test is crucial for accurate diagnosis. A positive McMurray Test is indicated by the presence of pain, a palpable or audible click, or a "pop" sensation felt by the examiner or reported by the patient during the specific maneuvers. The location of the pain or click helps determine which meniscus is affected.

**Positive for Medial Meniscus Tear:** Pain or a click/pop felt along the medial joint line during external rotation and knee extension. This suggests a tear in the medial meniscus.
**Positive for Lateral Meniscus Tear:** Pain or a click/pop felt along the lateral joint line during internal rotation and knee extension. This suggests a tear in the lateral meniscus.
**Negative Test:** No pain, clicking, or popping sensation is elicited during any of the maneuvers. While a negative test suggests the absence of a significant meniscal tear, it does not entirely rule it out, especially in cases of small or stable tears.

It's vital to note that a positive McMurray Test is just one piece of the diagnostic puzzle. Other findings from the physical examination, the patient's history, and potentially imaging studies are all considered for a definitive diagnosis. For instance, a tear in the meniscus may cause a pedunculated tag of the meniscus which may become jammed between the joint surfaces, leading to the characteristic symptoms observed during the test.

Accuracy, Limitations, and Complementary Diagnostics

While the McMurray Test is a widely used and valuable clinical tool, it's essential to understand its accuracy and limitations. The sensitivity and specificity of the McMurray Test vary in research studies, generally ranging from moderate to good. Some studies report a sensitivity of around 50-70% and specificity of 70-90% for detecting meniscal tears. This means that while it's reasonably good at confirming a tear when present (specificity), it might miss some tears (sensitivity).

Limitations of the McMurray Test include:

**Examiner Skill:** The accuracy of the test heavily relies on the experience and technique of the examiner.
**Patient Tolerance:** Severe pain or muscle guarding can make it difficult to perform the test effectively.
**False Positives/Negatives:** Other knee conditions (e.g., loose bodies, patellofemoral pain) can sometimes mimic a positive McMurray Test, leading to false positives. Conversely, small or stable tears might not elicit a positive response, leading to false negatives.
**Chronic Tears:** In chronic tears, the torn fragment might be less mobile, making it harder to elicit a click or pop.

Due to these limitations, the McMurray Test is rarely used in isolation for a definitive diagnosis. It serves as a strong indicator that prompts further investigation. When a meniscal tear is suspected, healthcare providers often recommend complementary diagnostic tests, such as:

**Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI):** MRI is considered the gold standard for non-invasive imaging of soft tissue structures in the knee, including the menisci. It provides detailed images that can confirm the presence, type, and location of a tear.
**X-rays:** While X-rays don't show cartilage, they can rule out other bone-related issues like fractures or arthritis.
**Arthroscopy:** In some cases, especially when other tests are inconclusive or for surgical planning, an arthroscopy (a minimally invasive surgical procedure where a small camera is inserted into the joint) may be performed. This allows for direct visualization and repair of the meniscus.

Learn how it works, what to expect, and when you might need other tests or treatments. The McMurray Test is a crucial orthopedic examination, but it is part of a larger diagnostic process to ensure accurate assessment and appropriate treatment planning for knee injuries.

Beyond Diagnosis: Treatment and Rehabilitation for Meniscal Tears

Once a meniscal tear is diagnosed, whether through a positive McMurray Test supported by imaging or other clinical findings, the treatment approach depends on several factors: the type, size, and location of the tear, the patient's age, activity level, and overall health. Treatment options range from conservative management to surgical intervention.

Conservative management typically involves:

**RICE Protocol:** Rest, Ice, Compression, and Elevation to reduce swelling and pain.
**Pain Management:** Over-the-counter pain relievers (NSAIDs) or prescription medication.
**Physical Therapy:** A structured rehabilitation program is often prescribed to restore range of motion, strengthen surrounding muscles (quadriceps, hamstrings), improve stability, and gradually return to activity. This is vital for long-term recovery and preventing re-injury.

Surgical options, often performed arthroscopically, include:

**Meniscus Repair:** If the tear is in an area with good blood supply (the outer "red zone"), the surgeon may be able to stitch the torn edges back together. This preserves the meniscus but requires a longer recovery period.
**Partial Meniscectomy:** If the tear is in an area with poor blood supply (the inner "white zone") or is irreparable, the damaged portion of the meniscus is trimmed away. This often leads to a quicker recovery but may increase the risk of developing arthritis later in life.

Rehabilitation after surgery is equally critical. It typically involves progressive exercises focusing on regaining strength, flexibility, and balance. Adherence to the rehabilitation protocol guided by a physical therapist is paramount for optimal outcomes and a successful return to daily activities or sports. Samarpan Physiotherapy Clinic, for example, provides comprehensive guides on understanding the McMurray Test, when it is needed, and what to expect from their treatment approaches.

Other "McMurrays": Disambiguating the Term

While the focus of this article has been on the medical diagnostic tool, it's worth noting that the name "McMurray" appears in other distinct contexts. It's a common surname, and as such, it's associated with various places and businesses globally. Two notable examples that sometimes cause confusion when encountered are:

**Fort McMurray:** This is a major urban service area in northeast Alberta, Canada. It is located in the middle of the Athabasca Oil Sands, surrounded by boreal forest, and has played a significant role in the development of the national petroleum industry. Unfortunately, it gained international attention due to the devastating 2016 Fort McMurray wildfire, which led to the evacuation of the entire community. This "McMurray" is a geographical location with significant economic and environmental relevance.
**Murray McMurray Hatchery:** This refers to a prominent business in the United States. Murray McMurray is known as the oldest and largest rare breed hatchery in the United States, specializing in poultry equipment and health care supplies. For those interested in poultry farming or rare chicken breeds, this "McMurray" is a well-recognized name in the agricultural sector.

These examples highlight how a single name can refer to vastly different entities. However, in the realm of orthopedic medicine and knee health, "the McMurray Test" unequivocally refers to the diagnostic procedure discussed extensively in this article.

Conclusion: Empowering Your Journey to Knee Recovery

The McMurray Test remains an indispensable tool in the initial assessment of knee injuries, particularly for suspected meniscal tears. Its ability to elicit specific symptoms by stressing the medial and lateral meniscus makes it a valuable part of any comprehensive orthopedic examination. Understanding how to perform the McMurray Test, how it works, and how to interpret its results is crucial for healthcare professionals, and knowing what to expect can be empowering for patients.

While a positive McMurray Test strongly suggests a meniscal injury, it's important to remember that it's a clinical indicator, not a definitive diagnosis on its own. It guides further investigation, often leading to advanced imaging like MRI for confirmation. Early and accurate diagnosis, followed by appropriate treatment and dedicated rehabilitation, is key to restoring knee function and preventing long-term complications. If you are experiencing knee pain or symptoms suggestive of a meniscal tear, do not hesitate to consult with a qualified healthcare professional. They can perform the necessary assessments, including the McMurray Test, and guide you through the most effective path to recovery. Share this article with anyone who might benefit from understanding more about knee health and this vital diagnostic test!

McMurray Roofing Ltd. | Fort McMurray AB

Larry McMurray

Taylor E. McMurray | Durham NC

Axios

Unlocking Knee Health: A Deep Dive Into The McMurray Test

Table of Contents